Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#1
So, I've started a series with a potentially low target audience for the writeathon. Multi-POV with non-likable/non-self-insert characters, Minor depression, Crude at times, SOL, Gamelit/Obscured LitRPG.
I am well aware both my defensive warnings/description and use of tropes that arn't popular won't get me a massive following, I'm mostly writing this series because I keep thinking about it/want to write it for myself and think at least a certain group of people will like it - I'd read it for example.
However, I'm also greedy and want followers and commenters hence me wanting to advertise and try and get some initial reviews in.
---
Open to review swaps from anyone that doesn't mind the tropes warned against. Completely fine with critical reviews as long as they arn't focusing on the points warned against - feel free to say my poise sucks or X doesn't make sense! I just don't want negative dings for "I don't like Multi POV series" or "I hate X character because they are an ass".
Down for both smaller reviews and advanced reviews - I'm really hoping for an honest review from someone who's reached my last chapter - chapter 10 - but I'll take what I can get.
Edit: 'The Achivement [System]' from my signature.
I am well aware both my defensive warnings/description and use of tropes that arn't popular won't get me a massive following, I'm mostly writing this series because I keep thinking about it/want to write it for myself and think at least a certain group of people will like it - I'd read it for example.
However, I'm also greedy and want followers and commenters hence me wanting to advertise and try and get some initial reviews in.
---
Open to review swaps from anyone that doesn't mind the tropes warned against. Completely fine with critical reviews as long as they arn't focusing on the points warned against - feel free to say my poise sucks or X doesn't make sense! I just don't want negative dings for "I don't like Multi POV series" or "I hate X character because they are an ass".
Down for both smaller reviews and advanced reviews - I'm really hoping for an honest review from someone who's reached my last chapter - chapter 10 - but I'll take what I can get.
Edit: 'The Achivement [System]' from my signature.
- Report this post
- Rep (10)
- Edited by Bluelightning42 at
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#2
I would've already written you a review by now regardless, if it weren't for the fact that Writathon was kinda kicking my ass, so I haven't read further in than Ch3. Guilty.
But, you can count on me! I'll find the time kinda soon. And this isn't a review swap, no need to write one back, I'm only at 9k words anyways, I don't care yet. Also I am legit a fan/reader and don't want my honest review tainted by the review-swap stamp, and for other readers to disregard it~
Also btw in the rules it says review swaps have to be advanced reviews, I'm pretty sure
Btw. to authors in this thread: I recommend review swapping with Blue, his story is really interesting, and he has a great eye for Royalroad fictions. Grassroots, closer to the readerbase than the some other authors that can come across as "out of touch". His reviews bang~
But, you can count on me! I'll find the time kinda soon. And this isn't a review swap, no need to write one back, I'm only at 9k words anyways, I don't care yet. Also I am legit a fan/reader and don't want my honest review tainted by the review-swap stamp, and for other readers to disregard it~
Quote:Down for both smaller reviews and advanced reviews
Also btw in the rules it says review swaps have to be advanced reviews, I'm pretty sure
Btw. to authors in this thread: I recommend review swapping with Blue, his story is really interesting, and he has a great eye for Royalroad fictions. Grassroots, closer to the readerbase than the some other authors that can come across as "out of touch". His reviews bang~
- Report this post
- Rep (7)
- Edited by Ararara at
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#3Ararara Wrote: I would've already written you a review by now regardless, if it weren't for the fact that Writathon was kinda kicking my ass, so I haven't read further in than Ch3. Guilty.
But, you can count on me! I'll find the time kinda soon. And this isn't a review swap, no need to write one back, I'm only at 9k words anyways, I don't care yet. Also I am legit a fan/reader and don't want my honest review tainted by the review-swap stamp, and for other readers to disregard it~
Quote:Down for both smaller reviews and advanced reviews
Also btw in the rules it says review swaps have to be advanced reviews, I'm pretty sure
Btw. to authors in this thread: I recommend review swapping with Blue, his story is really interesting, and he has a great eye for Royalroad fictions. Grassroots, closer to the readerbase than the some other authors that can come across as "out of touch". His reviews bang~
I'm caught up on your series! I would totally review it if you requested was just waiting on more chapters first.
Thanks for the vote of confidence.
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#4
Heyo! I've gotten dinged repeatedly purely because I'm experimenting with multi-POVs so I'm down.

Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#5PizzaPizza Wrote: Heyo! I've gotten dinged repeatedly purely because I'm experimenting with multi-POVs so I'm down.
Sure, I'll have an honest review for you in...2-3 business days at the latest
-min-AACAHCk7Xgw=.png)
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#6
I might have missed something but which of the books in your signature did you want a review on?
I also have 2 so if you want to do a double swap we can :)
P.s. many of my favorite books have many POV. (I.e. Wheel of Time) i don't think there is inherently anything wrong with it. It does take more skill to make it work though. It's a bit of higher risk but higher reward
I also have 2 so if you want to do a double swap we can :)
P.s. many of my favorite books have many POV. (I.e. Wheel of Time) i don't think there is inherently anything wrong with it. It does take more skill to make it work though. It's a bit of higher risk but higher reward
- Report this post
- Rep (11)
- Edited by zaifyr at
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#7zaifyr Wrote: I might have missed something but which of the books in your signature did you want a review on?
I also have 2 so if you want to do a double swap we can :)
P.s. many of my favorite books have many POV. (I.e. Wheel of Time) i don't think there is inherently anything wrong with it. It does take more skill to make it work though. It's a bit of higher risk but higher reward
Sorry one of my stories is completed and has enough reviews by far - I'm hoping for review swaps on 'The achievement [system]'/My writeathon attempt - updated in post.
Did you have a preferred story? Did you really want a double swap? I can do that as well even if it's not what I was advertising for.
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#8Bluelightning42 Wrote: Did you have a preferred story?Whichever you find more interesting. I would rather have you read something you might enjoy.
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#9Bluelightning42 Wrote: I'm hoping for review swaps on 'The achievement [system]'/My writeathon attempt - updated in post.
Thanks for the swap I had a lot of fun reading your story and your review!
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#10
Hey, would you be willing to do one more review swap?
My story has a slow start but it lays the groundwork for a more expansive story. Magic progression comes in later so you can choose to start from chapter 1 or from chapter 19 (where magic comes into play).
Let me know if you're interested
My story has a slow start but it lays the groundwork for a more expansive story. Magic progression comes in later so you can choose to start from chapter 1 or from chapter 19 (where magic comes into play).
Let me know if you're interested
- Report this post
- Rep (8)
- Edited by Thorgal at
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#11SomethingaboutRNG Wrote: Hey, would you be willing to do one more review swap?
My story has a slow start but it lays the groundwork for a more expansive story. Magic progression comes in later so you can choose to start from chapter 1 or from chapter 19 (where magic comes into play).
Let me know if you're interested
Sure, no problem. I can't get to it right away but I'll read through it over the next few days.
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#12Bluelightning42 Wrote:SomethingaboutRNG Wrote: Hey, would you be willing to do one more review swap?
My story has a slow start but it lays the groundwork for a more expansive story. Magic progression comes in later so you can choose to start from chapter 1 or from chapter 19 (where magic comes into play).
Let me know if you're interested
Sure, no problem. I can't get to it right away but I'll read through it over the next few days.
Thanks, that's all good for me, I'll write you a review early next week as well!
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#13
Hey! I'm taking my chance with this writathon and would like to have someone to just tell me what they think about my writing. I don't mind a negative review just looking for some criticism
English is not my first language so it'll probably show on my writing. at the moment i have around 15k words with each chapter being around 2k words. I'm starting slow but i don't know if it is too slow or if i'm jumping over some important things.
i'm always up to reading something new.
EDIT: I'm bringing my inner cringy edgelord to name the chapters, the story is a lot more chill.
English is not my first language so it'll probably show on my writing. at the moment i have around 15k words with each chapter being around 2k words. I'm starting slow but i don't know if it is too slow or if i'm jumping over some important things.
i'm always up to reading something new.
EDIT: I'm bringing my inner cringy edgelord to name the chapters, the story is a lot more chill.
- Report this post
- Rep (7)
- Edited by Dieguyto at
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#14Dieguyto Wrote: Hey! I'm taking my chance with this writathon and would like to have someone to just tell me what they think about my writing. I don't mind a negative review just looking for some criticism
English is not my first language so it'll probably show on my writing. at the moment i have around 15k words with each chapter being around 2k words. I'm starting slow but i don't know if it is too slow or if i'm jumping over some important things.
i'm always up to reading something new.
EDIT: I'm bringing my inner cringy edgelord to name the chapters, the story is a lot more chill.
Sure that's fine, I should be able to read through what you have within the next few days as well.
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#15Bluelightning42 Wrote: feel free to say my poise sucks or X doesn't make sense!
Edit: 'The Achivement [System]' from my signature.
Maybe you meant to write "prose"?
Anyway, I will review your work, give me until the end of the week. Should you like the review, there is no need to review my main work, it is overly long and probably hard to read. Instead, please check chapter two and one of my most recent chapters and let me know if my English has improved in any way (in my main work, Duty, in the signature). No need to read the entire chapters, just read as much as you can. If it is too much of a hassle, no problem, I was looking for a story to review this week anyway.
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#16
Hey what a fortuitous thread to stumble upon! Though we're probably still talking a couple weeks out, I'll be happy to read and review once writathon quits kicking my butt quite so hard.
It's the very least I can do after all the support you've shown my story.
It's the very least I can do after all the support you've shown my story.

Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#17Rookie12 Wrote:Bluelightning42 Wrote: ...
Maybe you meant to write "prose"?
Anyway, I will review your work, give me until the end of the week. Should you like the review, there is no need to review my main work, it is overly long and probably hard to read. Instead, please check chapter two and one of my most recent chapters and let me know if my English has improved in any way (in my main work, Duty, in the signature). No need to read the entire chapters, just read as much as you can. If it is too much of a hassle, no problem, I was looking for a story to review this week anyway.
"suffers prose damage for the spelling mistake"
You just want me to read chapter 2 and then a recent one? I'll read a few at different points and give comments in the chapters I guess? feel free to tell me if you want anything more than that.
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#18KileJ Wrote: Hey what a fortuitous thread to stumble upon! Though we're probably still talking a couple weeks out, I'll be happy to read and review once writathon quits kicking my butt quite so hard.
It's the very least I can do after all the support you've shown my story.
Ayy! I'm caught up on your fic so this is an easy review. I'll try and get it sooner rather than later.
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#19
Are you still willing? Because all those caveats sound awesome to me. I, too, have started a new story I'd love to get a review swap on. It's "I Suck At Titles" in my signature, and chapter 5 hits 10k words almost exactly.
Re: Review Swaps with lots of caveats.
#20Ellen Wrote: Are you still willing? Because all those caveats sound awesome to me. I, too, have started a new story I'd love to get a review swap on. It's "I Suck At Titles" in my signature, and chapter 5 hits 10k words almost exactly.
Ready and willing! Come one come all! I have tiny a bit of a backlog of takers as you can see, but I'll be able to get around to you this week.