Trading Reviews
#1
Good evening folks.
After finishing my last story and starting work on a new one, I'm hoping to work on some of the weaknesses that were pointed out in reviews and comments (despite them being greatly different genres!).
In light of this, I'd be greatly appreciative if anyone would be interested in trading reviews for A Scientific ReQuest.Especially since I posted 5 chapters throughout the day and I've already been given a 0.5 star rating.
I know it's not Shakespeare, but I'd really like to know that it's not that bad. Miraculously, the 0.5 rating has disappeared!
Post below if you're interested. I'm not a big fan of reading number boxes but I'll give most other things a go.
My current To-Do list:
Beverlyy – System Overload - Feedback and review completed!
Evil_Warlord – The Reincarnation of the Transcendental
Alt41 – 3 Bodies 1 Soul
Beast_regards – The Mook Maker
DukeFluffingtons - The Plagued Rat
After finishing my last story and starting work on a new one, I'm hoping to work on some of the weaknesses that were pointed out in reviews and comments (despite them being greatly different genres!).
In light of this, I'd be greatly appreciative if anyone would be interested in trading reviews for A Scientific ReQuest.

Post below if you're interested. I'm not a big fan of reading number boxes but I'll give most other things a go.
My current To-Do list:
DukeFluffingtons - The Plagued Rat
- Report this post
- Rep (2)
- Edited by Astrille at
Re: Trading Reviews
#2
Feel terrible about you getting a 0.5. Just looked at it and it's not that bad so far.
Alternatively we can do a feedback swap, or if you're looking for review swap I can do that too.
Alternatively we can do a feedback swap, or if you're looking for review swap I can do that too.
Re: Trading Reviews
#3Beverlyy Wrote: Alternatively we can do a feedback swap, or if you're looking for review swap I can do that too.
I'd be happy either way. That's the only issue with ratings. No idea what is working and what isn't.
Got a few lovely people leaving comments which is always good, but it's difficult to improve without any solid criticism to work on.
Re: Trading Reviews
#4
Hi. I am interested in a review swap if you wish. My story is called "The Reincarnation of the Transcendental" is in my signature. I will read your new story tomorrow. And as for the 0.5 rating you can open a support ticket and see if the moderators can check it out. I've seen many complain about trolls leaving such a low rating on the first chapter without reading too much. And after opening support tickets, the moderators have helped them with that. Although I must say that those kind of ratings unfortunately happen often.
Re: Trading Reviews
#5Evil_Warlord Wrote: Hi. I am interested in a review swap if you wish. My story is called "The Reincarnation of the Transcendental" is in my signature. I will read your new story tomorrow
That would be great! I'm heading off to sleep shortly so will read yours tomorrow too.
Thanks again!
Re: Trading Reviews
#6
Hi hi~~
I read the first 2 chapters of your novel and it seems great, I'm in~
I'll go continue reading before finishing your review~~ my story is in my signature~
I read the first 2 chapters of your novel and it seems great, I'm in~
I'll go continue reading before finishing your review~~ my story is in my signature~
Re: Trading Reviews
#8
Thanks, everyone! Especially those of you that have already provided reviews and feedback.
I have an official list on my top post and I promise I'll work through it asap.
Thank you especially Alt41 and beast_regards - Your kind reviews have really helped lift my mood
I have an official list on my top post and I promise I'll work through it asap.
Thank you especially Alt41 and beast_regards - Your kind reviews have really helped lift my mood

Re: Trading Reviews
#9
Hey there, I'd love to do a review swap. I'll check out your story tomorrow, first thing.
Cheers!
Cheers!
Re: Trading Reviews
#11DukeFluffingtons Wrote: Hey there, I'd love to do a review swap. I'll check out your story tomorrow, first thing.
Cheers!
Fabulous! I'll add your story to my list!