Dear Spellbook (Rewrite)

Dear Spellbook (Rewrite)

by TK523

Live. Study. Repeat.

Tal never saw himself as an adventurer, but the call to adventure never much cared for his opinion. Despite his best efforts, his search for answers on the murder of his parents ever draws him into danger. Accompanied by a group of seasoned warriors, thus far Tal has gotten by on his own meager magical talents, but when one day he wakes up to find himself back in his bed of the night before, he is faced with a challenge he must conquer alone.


What to expect:

This story was born of an attempt to create in world lore reasons for many of the mechanics and tropes of D&D, but you do not need to know of them to enjoy the story.

It's a single POV time loop story with slow paced progression fantasy elements. The story is not one of fast-paced power ups and non-stop action, but as it progresses, the action picks up. There is a lot of magic system exploration on a system built to unify the diverse magic of D&D into one cohesive magic system. The setting is an original world with familiar races and monsters but with new unique origins and motivations.

The average chapter will be 2-5k words long, most being around 3k but there are a few less than 1k, due to the nature of the story telling device I used.

Book 1 is complete. Posting is on hold until I finish book 2.

  • Overall Score
  • Style Score
  • Story Score
  • Grammar Score
  • Character Score
  • Total Views :
  • 242,582
  • Average Views :
  • 4,852
  • Followers :
  • 1,907
  • Favorites :
  • 248
  • Ratings :
  • 220
  • Pages :
  • 494
Advertisement
Remove
Go to Table of Contents
Rate it
Fiction breaking rules? Report
Advertisement
Remove
Author
TK523

TK523

Achievements
350 Comments
Word Count (13)
3rd Anniversary
200 Review Upvotes
Fledgling Reviewer (II)
250,000 Views
Top List #400
1,500 Followers
Advertisement
Remove
Table of Contents
50 Chapters
Chapter Name Release Date
Foreword ago
Chapter 1 - Dear Spellbook ago
Chapter 2 - Again? ago
Chapter 3 - Kobolds ago
Chapter 4 - No Vacationsies ago
Chapter 5 - Have You Seen My giant? ago
Chapter 6 - Clean at Last ago
Chapter 7 - Is This Dirt? ago
Bonus Chapter 1: Kordin's Chronicles ago
Interlude 1: Histories by Dwarves ago
Chapter 8: The Goat ago
Chapter 9: Salvation ago
Chapter 10: The First ago
Chapter 11: Count Your Blessings ago
Chapter 12: Memories ago
Chapter 13: The Cure ago
Chapter 14: The Report ago
Bonus Sketch 1: Spellbook ago
Chapter 15: Minions ago
Bonus Chapter 2: The Sea Tree ago
Chapter 16: Goblins ago
Chapter 17: Bearskin ago
Chapter 18: Benchmark ago
Chapter 19: Sorry! ago
Sketch 1: Bearskin ago
Chapter 20: Excrement? ago
Interlude 2: Project Proposal ago
Chapter 21: Mysteries ago
Chapter 22: Will Poisoning ago
Chapter 23: The Fall of Landing ago
Chapter 24: Debted ago
Chapter 25: Revenge is Okay Warm ago
Chapter 26: Breadth-First ago
Chapter 27: Love Struck ago
Chapter 28: Second Chance ago
Patreon Announcment ago
Chapter 29: The Best Defense ago
Chapter 30: Infiltration ago
Chapter 31: Preparation ago
Chapter 32: Hunted ago
Interlude 3: Mason Ants ago
Chapter 33: Descent ago
Chapter 34: Stone Eyes ago
Chapter 35: Teshiv ago
Chapter 36: Downtime ago
Chapter 37: Murder Most Accidental ago
Interlude 4: Mara ago
Chapter 38: Ensouled Artifacts ago
Chapter 39: Death and The Door ago
Interlude 5: The Dahn ago

Leave a review

drakan_glasses BE NICE! Fair critique is fair, but be respectful & follow the review rules. There will be no mercy.
Reviews
Sort by:
Korr4K
Overall

I don't mean this review as anything particularly negative.

I think I may have liked the novel, it's well written and what has been introduced about the worldbuilding and plot seems to be interesting enough. But I simply couldn't read more, it was just too much tedious.

Have you ever met somebody that constantly digress when they talk? Well, this MC is exactly like that, and because the entire novel is based around the concept of him using his spellbook as a diary, nobody is there to stop those digressions. Simple things like "I took a bath and then went to the library" require multiple long paragraphs. Finally, because the MC wasn't able to move on I had to do it, the experience wasn't enjoyable anymore.

 

Disclaimer: had a brief exchange of messages with the author. We agreed apon my point of view but he also suggested that I should stack some chapters and see how the novel evolves. I'll update my review in the future.

 

PS: this is why RR reviews are for the most useless and scores are inflated. Fanboys giving 5 stars left and right, and downvoting constructive reviews. You do understand that without proper feedback the authors can't improve themselves?

powered_by_coffee
Overall
Style
Story
Grammar
Character

Greeting my dear review observer!

Do not be surprised by the apparant early-ness of this advanced rev. This review is an update of my previous review on this book. I've read both versions of TK's "Dear Spellbook", the old and the new and I love all of the new content!

So, let us begin the digestion of the score:

This novel's lovely protagonist Tal is a sorcerer living in a world where sorcery has been outlawed and people who practice it are murdered and skinned alive, as is tradition.

To begin with, learning sorcery for the hero was a challenge, as it required his mom to place him into extremely dangerous, wilderness survival-type situations in which his talents and skills would emerge, but also he would be blessed with hypothermia and other ailments.

Secondly - our newly minted sorcerer must survive by pretending to be a wizard. Lucky he has a wizard's book on hand, which he mostly uses to draw caricatures of people he meets, pretending to be writing down spells.

Stylistically, this story has an interesting angle as it reads entirely from the point of view of Tal's wizard book, into which he logs daily journal entries. The book becomes bound to his soul, so the more he writes into it, the better he remembers events. The book's magic basically blesses him with eidetic memory.

Not mentioned in the description is the fact that Tal is trapped in a ground-hog day like situation in which he is repeating the same day. Slowly, over time the protagonist uses his book to understand the situation better and to also take advantage of it and of his perfect memory, by outsourcing event monitoring jobs - which is a creative and fun take on “the protagonist is stuck in a time loop idea” and is something that I’ve never seen in groundhog day type stories.

Spelling is pretty good, a lot of the old spelling errors that I had found in the previous version have been banished.

The world itself is full of rich detail and fun bits and feels deep as do the various characters that Tal interacts with from the comrade who is supposed to murder Tal for being a sorcerer to the kids whom Tal recruits for monitoring the loop events. Additional concepts such as - wizards who's daily, mundane job is to magically blow wind on ship sails to make boats go upriver make the world all the more believable.

The puns [such as trying to determine a name for yesterday-today] are creative and hilarious too, which is a plus.

luda305
Overall

Not bad. I appreciate the diary format, which is an unusual one, albeit challenging. 

The timeloop is fairly well handled.  Tal isn't like a super-genius or internet-weeb who's had to contemplate time loops before, so the pace as which he solves things seems to make sense, but feels good at the same time. 

My main concern is the alternating story bit.  There are actually two distinct stories here: The timeloop story, and the story of Tal becoming an adventurer (which predates the timeloop).  Both are good stories, but intermixing the two doesn't make any sense. Maybe they come together at the end, but for now, it's fairly discombobulated. 

 

WhimsicalDeity
Overall
Style
Story
Grammar
Character

A somewhat denser, slower-paced fantasy

Reviewed at: Interlude 1: Histories by Dwarves

A solid fantasy piece which follows a sorcerer stuck in a time loop. I think this is a well-written story, with the caveat that it's likely not going to be everyone's cup of tea, even if you're big on fantasy.

Style:

The book is written from the perspective of the main character writing into his spellbook in a fashion somewhat akin to writing a diary. That in and of itself is perfectly good, but due to his personality and how the spellbook interacts with his memory, the writing tends to be very dense.

I believe this was a purposeful choice on the part of the writer, as this is set up to be a slower-paced, more heavily world-built piece, but I do feel like there are limits. Many of the paragraphs in this piece will be true behemoths that I never see in other works, because each is often laden with a host of smaller details and side-thoughts. Expect many sentences to use em-dashes and asides as the character transcribes their somewhat garbled recollection of things.

The paragraph length and the many asides, taken together with the level of detail makes the reading feel a bit like a slog at times.

That being said, save for these quirks, the style is quite good from a technical perspective. Sentence structure is varied enough, the flow, accounting for the density of the work, is good, and we certainly get the level of detail we need to have everything click in our heads. If you're a fan of denser, slower pieces, this may well be an ideal read for you.

Story:

The story starts off with our MC in a party as an adventurer, and we're quickly shoved into the time-loop, right as one would expect. It's hard to gauge too much how well the story progresses, as I haven't learned much yet about the plot. There's someone the MC is searching for, but I've yet to learn why exactly, and most of the plot currently centers around the time-loop element.

Normally, not knowing enough would mean that I should just keep reading, but in this case, it feels like a pacing issue. I got a good ~20-25k words into the story, and I opted to stop because more time is spent building the world and giving us minor details about meals and baths than it is advancing the story. Once again, I believe that's a concious choice on the writer's part, but it feels like it was taken a touch too far here, and I struggle to keep myself invested in the plot at the pace it's delivered.

Aside from pacing, however, it seems quite inventive, with plenty of odd side-quests that appear to be set up for the future, and a wide variety of magic abilities and blessings that should keep things interesting.

Character:

Largely, I think the characters are good. Daulf is probably the most fleshed out of these, and has a very identifiable set of personality traits. To a lesser extent, other characters do as well, such as Roland and his habit of disappearing.

They've yet to be fleshed out much, and this early on, there's not much of an emotional investment in any of them, but I imagine that's something to be built in time. I would say that perhaps we could use a beat or two more of dialogue, as a lot of their character building rests on us being told about how they are rather than us being able to hear their personality shine through in their speech.

The MC is fairly enjoyable, if a touch dry in his humor and bearing. This, however, is fitting for the introverted book-worm type that he's built up to be, although it does mean that he can ocassionaly register as a touch flat emotionally, and we don't get too much in the way of him freaking out or showing heightened emotions.

Grammar:

Largely good. The work has a few typos, comma splices, and misplaced commas, but it's very solid overall. For those who care a lot about grammar, this is not a piece that will turn you off.

Sum:

In sum, I think it's well-written and interesting. I think it ends up being not quite my cup of tea, and I would go one step further to say I think the pacing and density of the work will make many other feel the same.

Ultimately, I would just suggest that you know what you're getting yourself into: If you enjoy binging faster-paced pieces where significant characer power-growth has taken place by chapter 10, then this is likely not the story for you. On the flip side, if you're tired of speedy books which don't offer enough detail and would like to strap yourself in for something denser, you may be in the right place.

SumGai
Overall
Style
Story
Grammar
Character

It's a great novel, but it does have shortcomings.

Reviewed at: Chapter 17: Bearskin

Currently at chapter 17: Bearskin

I love it, it's really a great novel and a great read, especially for someone like me who likes time loops and detailed world-building.

But I'm gonna try to try and keep this review as objective as possible, starting with the ever-so-present fact of time loop novels, and that is the slow pace. I'm not joking when saying that, up until now, we have had more flashbacks than the actual present story itself, and that's not something I'm sure anyone would really agree with, especially considering the info-dumpiness of the flashbacks, what with the novel being written as a diary that Tal wrote, and he has a habit of going on weird tangents and/or getting sidetracked.

even simple things are explained in detail, something I enjoy but I'm sure many will find it to be a slog to go through a full 4 paragraphs with each having 3~5 sentences about what the bath looks like.

Of course, it's not all negatives. For example, the grammar. Now, I'm not really the best at judging it, since extensive reading has given me a sort of auto-correct, but I haven't found any mistakes, and the reading isn't interrupted by weird choices of words. So I'm sure you'll probably have no problems with it.

The characters are also interesting, what with the fact that they're not two-dimensional, with our sorcerer MC in a world that hates his kind, a half-elf in hiding, a Blessed Chosen, and a player of a ranger.

Not to mention the extensive work that goes into the world-building, which is again a slog to go through if you don't like these types of novels, but for me, it's a great thing. The interludes give us a clear idea about the world's creation as well as mythology, as well as knowledge of its creators and the struggles they went through.

Bearskin
Overall
Style
Story
Grammar
Character

This review is based on the whole of Book 1, being a loyal and faithful companion to Tal—not like that, a comrade in arms—he let me read that book he carrier around everywhere.

 

This story is not to my typical tastes but I enjoyed it, especially the parts I am in. There is action, but it is not the focus of the tale. Tal is smart and goes often goes down rabbit holes of explanations of magic, and history, which did not surprise me since he is always talking about those things in our travel

 

The book is written in Tal’s perspective as he recounts his adventures in his spellbook using the magically enhanced memory it grants to give him an accurate account of the events. I have not read a lot of books, Tal taught me to read, but this is definitely a unique take.

 

I could not give the story a 5, since I do not appear in all the chapters. You are not graced with my majestic presence for some time, and all the while Tal dangles my name before you, making you wonder. The other reason I have story a 4 and not a 5 is that I prefer more action-packed stories with content battle and conflict. This story is more slow-paced, and the conflicts are interspersed with studying and experiments, which I understand some people love but it is not my cup of tea. I think that is the expression, where I come from, we do not drink tea.

 

The gRammar is good, though I am not a good judge.

 

The characters in this story are fantastic. In the beginning, Tal writes mostly of Daulf and Trish, who I will admit are admirable warriors, even if their styles of combat differ from my own as much as their personalities do. Roland is fine, he is a valued companion in battle, but not one I wish to share my fire with. Tal seems to have a good understanding of himself as he journals in his book. He may call himself a scholar, or a wizard, or a sorcerer, or a “Theral” but he is a warrior at heart. I will make him a warrior in arms and legs someday if he keeps up his training. He is introspective and can see his faults, which is a key aspect of a true warrior.

 

I am also in the story, and I am a great warrior whos exploits will be sung for generations to come. I do not brag, I speak only the truth. Don’t take my word for it, take Tal’s.

 

Overall I give this story 5 stars. I chose not to penalize it for delaying my appearance.

Halfcrzy
Overall

Feels like the re-write may need a re-write

Reviewed at: Chapter 30: Infiltration

Now I had previously read the other-older version of this. I had thought there were some hiccups along the way, but it was a pretty decent story. Then the hiatus, and the re-write. I thought oh goodie, lets cut down on the useless monologue parts, slow parts, half thought out parts and make this the best version possible.

Well the first dozen chapters were near identical, titles almost the same. Same long boring monologues that bring the story no further ahead, I had wondered what even changed?

The MC is the POV, and is still the biggest weakness. Feel like theres is major character conflicts going on in the planning department. Recently dead parents, time to grieve? No, time to make jokes frequently. Goes out of his way to help people, but also suspects bad intentions it seems. Extremely paranoid he is trapped with others in a time loop? Proceeds to just bath and read short stories for fun. 

Where is the urgency? Why doesnt he ask others for help? Why does he treat his diary like a human conversation? After learning his situation, why hasnt he taken full advantage of it yet to improve?

TL;DR this is pretty much the same as pre re-write novel. Glaring problems and all.

Sparks2020
Overall

Very cool, looking forward to more

Reviewed at: Chapter 7 - Is This Dirt?

First off, I never read the original version of this story, I understand that this is a relaunch-rewrite. Well, I like it!

The perspective of Tal, a new(ish) sorcerer who survives in a world which is hostile to magic, is interesting. I particularly like the beginning, where 'if you're reading this, I'm dead' really captures your attention. 

Definitely going to be following this story, it's well crafted, with few it any grammar or spelling mistakes, and some great world-building.

Buller
Overall

Dear [Insert obscure reference]

Reviewed at: Chapter 6 - Clean at Last

Review from old story ahead. Most things fit fine though style has improved. Reads smoother than before. 

Now.

This story has a style that some might find off-putting, getting very close to what I would call a diary type of writing. Or, should I call that a spellbook style of writing? Is there any difference? I don't care. Maybe there is.

Anway, such a style doesn't encompass doesn't the whole story, readers still able to get a view outside of it in some fashion. It's still much more descriptive from my perspective but whatever. I like it and that's all that matters here.

Characthers should be experienced at one's own leisure. So... go read it. 5/5 from me.

Silicis
Overall

A lot of fun and very different.  A nice fresh take on the genre. I like the interactions amd characters as well as the character development. I look forward to the finished work and will be 100% following the author. Here is hoping to a long amazing career.  10 out of 10