Rebirth in a Magical World

Honestly i think this is the best "fanfic" i have ever read, it doesn't just throw the MC into all of Harry's scenarios, instead starting several years earlier than any of the books and crafting an awesome original storyline making use of forgotten side characters and new original characters, heck i'm 43 chapters in and i don't even think i can remember "Harry Potter" be mentioned once.

The only critisism i could even make is a few cases of incorrect grammar and questionable choice of words / phrases that can throw you for a loop, but all the series really needs is a proof reader, and the grammar does improve in more recent chapters as the author has been putting up google docs where the readers can make note of mistakes.

All and all i would highly recommend, this fanfic is awesome, at 43 chapters in we have just reached the end of year 1 with the author mentioning 7 years have been planned, so hopefully we can strap in for the long haul, i look forward to reading everything this author gives us.

Going into this story was a bit of a rollercoaster at first, based on reviews I had rather high expectations but seeing the rather mediocre grammar quickly lowered them.

Yet as I read I found myself blown away by how far beyond this exceeded what I was expecting! the author (not to be rude) is some random dude with no other works and hasn't even been on RR a year and yet he manages to weave fascinating Harry Potter lore and a perfect portrayal of the characters we've all seen in the books into a quality story that remains both unique, lore and timeline friendly and most importantly forces you the spend hours binging the story only to be crushed that you've reached the latest chapter!

I might be a bit excessive saying this, but I believe that with good grammar this story might even contend with the works of Lone or L. Nimbus.

The story is almost original but set in the harry potter universe. The story is not tightly constrained by the harry potter but does tie in events in the books with an original story.

The writting is rather good, the length of chapters are longish but not boring or incoherent (Not a bad length for a book chapter). A couple of spelling mistakes or missing words (very minimal).

The MC's character is easy to read and MC doesn't seem to have to much plot armour so far, most encounters the MC spends time thinking before doing.

The story evolves around Alexander Frawley, a reincarnated 15 year old boy gets the chance live as he was stuck in a hospital for 14/15 years. As a fan of the Harry Potter books I fell in love with this novel because the story stands on its own feet. The story evolves around the the books without interfering in its story to much as Alex is in the same school year as Fred and George and makes so much more of the Harry Potter universe than Jk Rowling ever did , just to name a few things the author adds to the original story he explores more and deeper magic, characters (new and old), dueling clubs, wild live, more world wide Wizarding society, countries, criminal organizations and much more. It doesn't break any "rules" of Jk Rowling and adds much more without reading what we already know of the story.

Alex knows most stuff that happens in the first 5 books wich sets the plot up great as the "important" stuff really takes of in book six, so no knowledge of hocruxes and how the major game is going to end in the books. Alex has his own story, own family (great and realistic characters), new enemies (OP In a way) and friends without interfering in Harry's story at all. 

Alex is a more powerful wizard (like Tom) but hasn't really been that great as even the best ones need a lot of years until he can stand on par with Dumbledore and Tom. As an isekai story he doesn't fell into the trap of being actually much older than his age suggest because he was shackled to a hospital bed for all his live without making any experience at all. The characters are well written and fleshed out. The story in general is well written an deep as he is committed to try and save some guys who die in the 4th and  5th book (not all) without interfering with the "mane" story wich is great story telling. Alex researches new magic, invents new stuff and prepares for voldi and the bigger enemy of his family. 

I fell in love with the story, it's characters, plot, world building and feel invested into Alex's characters (good and bad xD). I am looking forward what choices are going to be made, how he wants to deal with all the stuff that will come his way down the line. 

Great Story, characters, plot, normal comedy(not much actually, which I like), deep lore, he builds up his own live and makes mistakes (he doesn't act like an OP wizard at all and it won't help him that much because the enemy is just impossible to beat alone) 

Best Story an rr for me as I am looking forward to everything that is going to come in the story. Once I was angry at the story for being/evolving around the HP story (he is 2 years above him) but was wrong to doubt the author and quickly fell in love with the plot and the characters. Life ain't easy and alex although he knows some stuff, will be just a bumpy as life can be. I'm thrilled to have found the story on rr and am amazed with the ongoing potential of the story. Will he be part of any of the order of the Phoenix stuff, or will he be thrown to the death eaters (family bonds and stuff xD)

I am excited of what will come, and play out ideas what will happen in the future in my head witch only few books have ever made me do. 

Thanks for the story author and give yourself a cold as beer and look into the sunsety friend, you truly deserve it for all the thought and work you put into your novel to make it as exciting as it is to date. 

PS.: I am not native so sorry for my English :) 

Can't wait for more. I love the character development and I often found that while reading I would stop reading to watch the movies to spot where alex would be in that instance. Surprisingly I have found that he could be canon and just never shown in the movies so far.

Ps: Read all of it while being logged out, so it was only showing I am up to chapter two when I have finished it and want more lol

I have to say that this is probably one of the best fanfics that I've read.  Not that I read much fan fiction, but this is turning into a great novel that I'm really enjoying.  The author is inhabiting J.K. Rowling's world without to many bumps and adding depth to this universe.  While there are gramatical errors, they don't distact from the story.  

I'm really enjoying the trip back to Hogwarts and hope that the author stays on track.  Keep up the good work Flying JMW!!!  

I usually stay away from fan-fictions, as they generally aren't very well written. That isn't the case with this novel. While it stays true to the HP world, it doesn't really rehash the original storyline. There are many details that are well though of, that fit into the world seemlessly. Also, the main character has a very different life experience from Harry Potter, which provides a fresh perscpective. Another positive for me, which can be off-putting for some, is that at the start of the book the MC comes off as very arrogant and stupid at times (he keeps making stupid decisions because he is ahead in his studies.) This gets better as he gets older, as he realizes that he can very easily die, and that he has to think more before commiting to doing something dangerous. All in all, I would suggest this book to all fantasy lovers, even people who haven't read/seen Harry Potter. 

I really enjoyed this fanfiction. My only other Harry Potter fan fic for comparison is Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality, which sets an extremely high bar.
I'm pleased to report that this fan fic is within spitting distance of it. I was entirely engrossed and captivated living out my Harry Potter universe fantasies vicariously through the main character.

How dare the author not have a patreon 40 chapters ahead I can throw money at them to access. Already feeling the withdrawal symptoms after catching up. Y'all got any more of them chapters?

Simply amazing the plot ,the story, the characters are just the right thing up my alley the interactions between family feels so natural and funny that I always look forward to it love that side characters are very present and love the added magic explanation to think this was the authors first book .I have to say this is one of the most brilliant fabrics I've ever read it adds so many brilliant ideas that this feels like a real story as in a fanfic when I finished I couldn't go back to my normal books compare to this masterpiece they fell very dull . to the author I have to say please continue writing I really enjoy the story and can't wait to see what's in store for Alex in the future .