Dungeon Ecologist

I like the general story, direction and characters of this book.

However I can't get rid of the feeling of disharmony between certain story points. It's like having a jigsaw where the pieces don't fit together, you can overlap them to see the great picture but there are slot of holes in it that produces questions that I'm not sure the author can answer.

 ^

This is basicly what I think is weird about the series and some plot points/conspiracy ideas that I think could fit to make the setting work, if they are revealed later on to the clueless protagonist.

Writing this review in the early days, but enjoying it greatly so far! Having read a significant number of various dungeon stories on Royalroad over the past few years, I feel confident in saying that this is a different twist on the dungeon master trope, one which if kept up on, looks to have promise! Worldbuilding very much happens, but at a relaxed comfortable pace; no massive infodump here, it happens naturally as the protagonist interacts with various parts of the world.  No grammer problems jarred me out of reading, and the story flowed nice and smoothly. Just a tad too much inner monologue for my taste, but what do I know, as it fit into the tale based on what we know of the main character. Looking forward to future updates!

(as of chapter 8) As the story has just started, this review might change drastically later, but so far, the story is looking promising.

Basil is a freshly graduated 'Dungeon Maker', a Class that is the basis for the world's economy but which doesn't bring any fame or excitement with it. Instead of starting a long-term slave-like internship like everybody else, he decides to become self-employed. He manages to obtain his first assignment, but the terms and conditions he naïvely signs... uh oh, he better not mess up!

The concept of the story is very unusual, especially because RRL is full of dungeon core stories: In 'Dungeon Ecology', creating a dungeon is not the managerial and livestock-husbandry-like task of an overmind-broodmother hybrid, instead it is the creative job of an architect together with a fair bit of bricklaying and plumbing. In the first chapters the readers are introduced to the basics of the world, of dungeon making prerequisites and to a handful of people.

The story is told in first-person internal style from Basil's POV, thus we quickly learn about his inner thoughts, his strengths and some of his faults. Those few other characters that have been introduced are so far only rather simple personalities, but you can't expect better after just a short dialogue or two and a total story length of 41 pages. There have been some explanations about how the world works. Those might feel a bit infodumpy to some readers but they are inserted adequately into the inner monologue of the MC while we listen to his thoughts. The amount of descriptions is okay but they are not very detailed yet. Grammar is good and I found almost no typos.

In total, 'Dungeon Ecology' looks like it could become a very interesting new experience; *followed*

These last moths, I read many stories wth dungeons as thema. The classics, reincarnation as a dungeon in a fantasy world, variants in a science fiction environment, another type was the dungeon cooperating with the adventurers or being pacific. And we have also the dungeons on our Earth, quite frequently, Earth is integrated in a System, and the dungeons grow as mushrooms.

The interesting difference here, is the idea that a class can create dungeons, the author in this first few chapters, has well imagined the consequences of that possibility. I wait with impatience the developments of this story.

I was quite sad when the hiatus started and am relieved that it is over so that I can read the chapter as soon as they are wrote again!

So the MC in this novel isn't some overpowered god like being so thats a +1 straight off the bat! It has in tbteresting concept and I can't wait to see how the story continues! 

It's early days yet for this story, but I'm really looking forward to seeing where it goes. The writing is solid, the worldbuilding is good and the characters distinctive without being caricatures.

the premise is interesting. It doesn’t seem like it will become a standard dungeon core story. However, as of chapter 8 it feels like we have just passed the introduction so I will follow progress and review more in depth later on.

gramatically is seems to be good and the mc seems believable.

 Five Stars based on his previous books. His previous books were all 10/10 and he knew how to do it. Will do an actual review at around chapter 20.