This fic has been rewritten and improved, go to the rewritten version!

 

 

 

 

  • Overall Score
  • Style Score
  • Story Score
  • Grammar Score
  • Character Score
  • Total Views :
  • 338,356
  • Average Views :
  • 6,905
  • Followers :
  • 913
  • Favorites :
  • 131
  • Ratings :
  • 313
  • Pages :
  • 293
Advertisement
Remove
Go to Table of Contents
Rate it
Fiction breaking rules? Report
Advertisement
Remove
Author
The Irregular

The Irregular

Night Owl

Achievements
Top List #400
Fledgling Reviewer (II)
15 Review Upvotes
250,000 Views
1,250 Followers
Word Count (13)
4th Anniversary
750 Comments
Advertisement
Remove

Leave a review

drakan_glasses BE NICE! Fair critique is fair, but be respectful & follow the review rules. There will be no mercy.
Reviews
Sort by:
Steve Moss
Overall

Good story so far.  I especially like the characterization of Three and his fellow test subjects.

One irritation about the most recent chapter.  Declaring a weapon is the only one they'll ever use defies reality.  A maul, two handed sword, or battle axe may be great in some circumstance (when one has space to move) but horrible in others.  In narrow or low corridors, other weapons will be needed.  In a shield wall, other weapons will be needed.  In a thick forest, other weapons will be needed.  Different armor types are countered by different weapons.  Ditto with the boy who declared he'll only use a long bow.  Much like a financial plan, never put all your eggs in one basket.  Diversify.

Gibbson
Overall
Style
Story
Grammar
Character

Something to read in between everything else

Written as of chapter 37

 

Interesting story but feels a bit dull or flat -- hard for me to describe but I'll try.

Style is pretty standard no unique flair or weird structure or anything. The author shows more than he tells -- thank god. There is nothing difficult about reading this story.

Grammar is alright a clunky sentence here or rather far over there, no jarring misspellings or anything like that. The author at the very least can write at a functioning level, I dont need to do mental gymnastics yo understand him, what I mean is I've written worse things in college. 

When it comes to the story and character scores it's really subjective to the reader some people love it, some hate it and other will tolerate it, personally I'm more in the 3rd category. Also the part of the review will be kinda spoilery.

Spoiler: Spoiler

 

Truth be told if this was a D&D campaign I'd complain that its been railroaded.

Its a story to read because you are waiting on other stories to be updated and its a way to kill time, It's no where near as good as Fel's "Sennedar" or Robert Jordan's "Wheel of Time" but its definitely better than my childhood ninja fanfics.

Karolus
Overall

I have read a number of LitRPG stories and this is one of the easier ones to read. The premise is intriguing and the story doesn't bog down too much in the early going.

If there is one constant complaint, it is the niggling grammar and spelling errors, they are distracting, but not overly detrimental. Other than that, some of the characters are not well defined yet, but that may be more a function of length than anything else.

Aethelheim
Overall
Style
Story
Grammar
Character

Read until chapter 4, and I will keep my explanation short.

So far the story have successfully built a very strong background and introduction to it's characters. I can only hope that it keeps it that way. I am now looking forward to see how the author will showcase the outside world.

Keep up the good work! 

Ps. A character sheet over the eight people would be nice :)

Horst
Overall
Style
Story
Grammar
Character

Well let's get this review started.

The fact that you have 8 MCs is in itself not bad BUT you really lose the feel for all the characters except Three because they simply don't have enough exposure in the novel.

8 MCs can work and i like the idea of the white room but because you split the MCs so early in the story, i lost the feel for the other MCs really fast and although i like the idea of the white dream/room i find myself skipping those chapters almost completely because i'm just not interested in their story. 

This leads to the general Story and World. The world itself is nice and well described. The story on the other hand feels really artificial, like everything that happens, happens at the authors convenience. 

The style is fine, although nothing especially stunning. The grammar is fine and you can read it easily but i think i read a few mistakes here and there.

 

So to sum it up it's an average story that has some issues but  hopefully will solve some of them. I recommend rethinking the start of the novel.

The part up to their escape is fine but after that the story starts to lose focus.

 

P.S.: What really rubs me the wrong way on this site is that almost nobody rates properly on this site, the least reviews have proper scoring most just automatically give 5 stars despite clear issue in the novels.

fanobody
Overall

It was a good start for the story but it was a major letdown that the author has dropped this story because two people had put a 0.5 star on this story. It is like all the other people that put a five star don't even count.

The story is good in itself. I didn't like the prologue and it should be remade, but the rest of the story makeup for this. The interaction between personnage is well done. The author is new and is very ambitious with the pov but it was still less interesting than the main story and the pov didn't add to the main story like game of throne do so well.

The game mechanic were new with nice skill but could do some work as it make no sense that a parent give their child the right to put their point were they want when were they put their point could change their future and stats were not put in use(You could have made the same story witout stats and it would not be a big change). 

Greekreader
Overall
Style
Story
Grammar
Character

Generally better than most

Good story, well written, has some slight errors but they are few and far between. it's a good book to read truthfully, the author has talent keeping things together, while also being able to make you feel more invested in characters as time goes on, the only suggestion I would make to the author would be to kill off a pov character or three to keep it down from pov changes while this would also allow faster progression. Overall though it is a good read and I would recommend it.

dosithee
Overall

Cool start but ultimatly dissapointing.  Characters interactions are boring as is the world.  

iansacdalan
Overall

It's a great story so far (I'm in Chapter 15).Wrong Spelling and Grammar is a bit distracting.

tenaciouspfc
Overall
Style
Story
Grammar
Character

(SPOILERS IN REVIEW)

 

This story is well done and deserves to be read. There are minor grammar mistakes (I've read stories with far worse grammar) but it's not really an issue. The MC and his friends are great. I really like how their situation is set up and how their powers work.

An MC like Three is interesting b/c of his background in the sense that a lot of stories have MC's that have similar background yet they either don't have "siblings" that went through the bad stuff with him, or they were summoned from another world and they can't speak like the MC or have other issues. However those characters have their earth knowledge and are mentally weak at first.

I also find it pretty cool how the MC is a tank/Brawler type yet chose to be a monster tamer. Yeah, maybe other stories have monster tamers, but not stories that have MC's like ours or if they do, it's only like 1 or 2 companion pets or something. Atleast on RR that is.

 

I would recommend this to others as it is worth reading. Any complaints I had (which was the MC and his friends giving out their backgrounds too easily) seems to be being addressed. 

 

So, thanks author and please give us more!